DiNapoli report highlights lump-sum spending, reduced transparency in budget
Apr 27, 2018
New York’s state’s $168.3 billion budget reduces transparency and oversight measures, expands “back-door borrowing” and includes new lump-sum appropriations, according to a report released Friday by state Comptroller Tom DiNapoli.
The spending plan addresses federal tax changes and increases the state’s investment in education and healthcare, DiNapoli said, but the lack of oversight and irresponsible borrowing puts the state at risk.
“I am concerned that the budget expands public authority back-door borrowing and fails to build up rainy day reserves.” DiNapoli said. “While revenues are currently strong, it’s important to monitor trends moving forward including the ongoing impact of federal tax and budget actions.”
One of the largest of lump-sum appropriations in the spending plan is a $475 million allocation for the State and Municipal Facilities Program, or SAM – a 23 percent increase from last year –even though the majority of previous appropriations for the program remain unspent, according to the report.
“The need for additional discretionary spending authority was not made clear in the enacted budget,” DiNapoli said.
SAM, which has been appropriated a total of $2.4 billion over the last five years, is used by the state Dormitory Authority to fund capital projects. Critics note that its statutory criteria grows broader with each passing budget and that the governor and Legislature use the funds for pet projects. The 2018-19 budget expands an extensive list of entities that may benefit from the funds to include nonprofit organizations, sanitation districts, special districts, regional transportation authorities and the New York City Health and Hospitals Corporation.
The enacted budget also authorizes public authorities to borrow an additional $6.5 billion on behalf of the state, a 21.5 percent increase from what was authorized in Gov. Andrew Cuomo’s initial budget proposal. Of the borrowed funds, SAM benefits from an additional $398.5 million, according to DiNapoli’s analysis.
Fiscal watchdogs have long criticized the state for using SAM as “a credit card” and for the program’s lack of transparency.
“Number one, this money is not being used to fund public priorities. Number two, it’s using borrowed money and forcing future taxpayers to pick up the tab for politicians to win political points today,” said Ken Girardin, policy analyst at the right-leaning Empire Center for Public Policy.
When asked about the comptroller’s findings, a budget spokesperson for Cuomo’s office argued that padding the SAM program provides additional flexibility to react to needs that emerge during the fiscal year.
“Every dollar of spending must meet the statutory and program requirements established within appropriation language and be subject to a rigorous agency review process,” Cuomo spokesman Morris Peters said. “The idea that we’d know exactly what the year will bring with no contingencies is simply unrealistic and a recipe for gridlock.”
DiNapoli’s report questions why the state has not put away more rainy day funds. While in December, the state appeared to be facing a significant budget shortfall, the state ended the fiscal year with $1.7 billion additional revenue compared to a year earlier, due to stronger tax revenues late in the year, unexpected settlements and lower-than-projected spending. DiNapoli called it “a missed opportunity to better prepare for the next economic downturn.”
The comptroller acknowledged that the budget was enacted on time — or prior to the April 1 deadline — but noted that as usual, most budget bills were rushed to passage with “messages of necessity,” leaving little time for review.
Other findings in DiNapoli’s report include:
Increases General Support for Public Schools by $863 million, or 3.4 percent, and provides an additional $50 million in competitive grants for prekindergarten, after-school and other programs. Foundation Aid is expected to increase by $618 million.
Provides more funding to the MTA, including off-budget proceeds from new surcharges on taxi trips and other for-hire transportation in Manhattan, starting in January 2019. The budget also requires New York City to make contributions for capital and operating costs associated with the plan or risk losing state aid.
Creates the Secure Choice Savings Program, a voluntary, state-administered retirement savings plan for private sector and nonprofit employees.
Relies on an estimated $186 million in new tax and assessment revenues, including $100 million from opioid manufacturers and distributorsand the impact on business taxes of decoupling from the Internal Revenue Code. It also authorizes the state to use certain health plan reserves of up to $750 million annually for a multi-year period, potentially generating billions of dollars to fund a variety of health and other programs.
Establishes a new Health Care Transformation Fund to pay for health care programs and other purposes, with authority to transfer moneys to any other state fund at the discretion of the budget director.
Holds flat most direct aid to local governments. Aid and Incentives to Municipalities, the largest unrestricted aid category for cities, towns and villages, is funded at $715 million, the same level since SFY 2011-12.
Maintains the appropriation for the Environmental Protection Fund at $300 million.
Creates a New York State 2020 Complete Count Commission to recommend steps to be undertaken to ensure an accurate count of New Yorkers in the next U.S. Census.
Includes a revised version of an Executive proposal requiring disclosure of the identities of entities or individuals making expenditures for certain paid Internet or digital political communications but omits several other Executive proposals related to public campaign financing, other campaign finance reforms, and early voting.